Friday, July 29, 2011

Some thoughts on one movie rating...

I haven't seen the new "Winnie the Pooh" movie. However, I do have a question about its rating. According to Jay Leno's Headlines, and also seen in this link to a movie review, "Winnie the Pooh" is rated G for "(violence, profanity)." This begs the questions:

1. Exactly how much violence and profanity can a G-rated movie have?

2. Isn't it really rated G for everything? Obviously not "Winnie the Pooh," but, if a movie only has G-rated violence and profanity and several shots of full-frontal nudity, it's rated R for the nudity. (Then again, Winnie the Pooh doesn't wear pants, and I don't think Tigger or Eeyore wear anything.)

3. Exactly how much violence and profanity has there ever been in "Winnie the Pooh?" Is somebody misunderstanding words like "Pooh" and "heffalump?"

(OK, I know I'm making way too much out of what's almost certainly an editing mistake, but the idea of a movie rated G for violence and profanity still amuses me.)

Labels: , , , ,

Saturday, April 16, 2011

Ramdom thoughts on the Atlas movie...

Usually, I'm not too particular about when I see movies that I want to see. Often, as long as I see it on the big screen, whenever will be fine. The movie "Atlas Shrugged, Part 1" is different--knowing how much stock Hollywood puts into opening weekend returns, I want to see the movie this weekend; I'd have seen it opening night if the mall weren't a madhouse on the weekends. Ever since I heard about it, it's been at the top of my list for upcoming movies.

What I'm trying to figure out is why I want to see the movie so badly when I've already read and reread the book. For movies where I haven't read the book, the movie is a quick and easy way to experience the story. However, my enthusiasm in this case seems more difficult to explain.

I suppose it's possible that it's a quick way to experience the book again. As with the books where the movie is the quick way to see what's it about for a first time, it could also be a quick way to experience it again.

Somewhat going against that idea, though, it occurs to me that seeing the movie is a way to see the book as others envision it and get new perspective on it.

A third idea is that the simple idea that a good novel would represent a solid start on the way to making a good movie. This one may apply a bit less to the "Atlas Shrugged" movie than most cases--the movie was made by an entrepreneur who has never produced a movie before, the director has little experience, and I've never heard of most of the stars, and the budget is small by Hollywood standards. So, while I like the actress who's playing Dagny, I have some apprehensions about how the movie will come out.

I think the main reason I'm looking forward to the movie so much, however, is that it's a way to celebrate the book. It's a way of going out and saying, "this is a great book--pay attention!" One reason why I tend to lean most heavily on this theory is that I've been trying to urge Donald to see the movie--alas, it seems, to no avail. I also tend to think this is the case because I really want to see it opening weekend so it'll have good returns in the way the movie industry seems to care about, and have them despite the limited release.

Regardless, though, I'm glad to finally see that Atlas Shrugged will make it to the big screen.

Labels: , , , ,

Sunday, March 15, 2009

Old English/New Mistake

"Monday on 'Good Morning Jacksonville,' the works of Shakespeare were done in Old English, but one performance troupe has found a way to translate it into hip hop."
The above quote is from a commercial that aired during Saturday's "Jeopardy!" I caught one grammatical error (the antecedent for "it" is "the works of Shakespeare") and one factual error (Shakespeare wrote in Early Modern English). I don't think I can deal with journalism such as this at 6AM on Monday.

Labels: , ,

Thursday, September 11, 2008

Lipstick on a pig


If you're wondering why I'm already sick to death of the election cycle, this whole "lipstick on a pig" brouhaha is a perfect example. Let me share a few thoughts on the subject.

1. I don't for one moment believe McCain, Palin, or any of their partisans actually believe that Obama called Palin a pig, or meant to. Cut the crap. If this is a comment that merits an apology, then let's also demand to hear one from McCain, Cheney, Petraeus, and everyone else who has used this expression also.

2. As long as I'm questioning the sincerity of the Republicans' indignation, I would note that Palin compared herself to a dog with the original joke. "Pig" is not much better or worse than "dog." "Bitch" and "dog" are insults themselves. At this point, I would wonder if the whole point of that stupid joke was to create a lipstick reference so that if Obama used the cliche, they could cry foul over nothing.

3. Being fair to both sides, if Obama is as great a rhetorician as his partisans claim he is, why on earth is he using such a hackneyed old cliche?

4. Getting back to McCain and Palin, if they're really this mad over such a trivial perceived insult, then you certainly shouldn't want either in the oval office. It would be extraordinarily dangerous to the human race to have such a sensitive temper in control of the nuclear trigger. If these two get elected, you can count on four years of Ahmadinejad, Chavez, Castro, etc., using the word pig to excess.

5. Am I the only person who has noticed that there is very little discussion of agricultural policy in all this discussion of pigs? Or any real issue, for that matter?

Labels: ,

Sunday, July 20, 2008

Home on derange

In my blog entry about the railroad sites in Colorado, I just want to know why the spell checker thought it would be a good idea to change "Durango" to "Derange."

They're helpful for proofreading, but sometimes the spellchecker is just deranged.

Labels: ,

Sunday, April 20, 2008

This mistake always leaves me shaken up.

No! No! No!

In an article about the recent Mt. Carmel, IL, earthquake, CNN wrote, "The epicenter of the earthquake -- the strongest in the region in 40 years -- was about seven miles below ground and 38 miles north-northwest of Evansville, Indiana, the USGS said."

That was wrong. CNN was wrong, period. The epicenter was probably 38 miles north-northwest of Evansville, but it was not seven miles below the ground. The focus likely was seven miles below ground. However, the epicenter is ALWAYS on the SURFACE of the earth. Without exception. Ever. That's what "epicenter" means.

Labels: ,

Wednesday, January 09, 2008

A cranky wordsmith reacts to being told "no."

OK, I'm the first to admit some words are overused. From a year and a half in the computer industry in the late '90s, I still have a hatred of the word "robust"--which I still feel better describes spaghetti sauce than software.

However, I am disinclined to alter my writing because of similar opinions from Lake Superior State University. Some of their over-used words, such as "a perfect storm," "back in the day," or "give back" are over used. "Give back" is particularly grating to me--call that a side-effect of reading too much Ayn Rand.

However, some, such as "post-9/11" or "webinar" (which I don't consider overused since I've never heard it) would seem to have a proper place.

I'm left to conclude that I should ignore the expert opinions in this case. To invoke another phrase I find myself using a lot in casual conversation, sure to invoke the ire of the list-makers, it is what it is.

Labels: , ,

Thursday, December 13, 2007

W00t the heck?

Call me old-fashioned, call me linguistically conservative, call me uncool--Merriam-Webster's word of the year for 2007--"w00t"--is not a word. It has numbers--those two zeros are supposed to be there--or at least as much as zeros are ever supposed to be in a "word." "Woot" isn't a word, either.

Don't believe me? Go to Merriam-Webster's own website and try looking up "w00t." As of now you'll get this page--which begins with the sentence, "The word you've entered isn't in the dictionary." and goes on to suggest 20 alternatives , including such prescient ones as "hoot," "ought," and "outlaw."

This is what happens when lexicographers lose their minds!

Labels: ,

Thursday, September 20, 2007

The SLUT gets around...

Some stories get around more than either a streetcar or a promiscuous woman. One is how Seattle's new South Lake Union Streetcar has been unofficially renamed the South Lake Union Trolley. This has been reported near and far.

This isn't the first railroad acronym to inspire snickers. Switzerland's F.A.R.T. has been in business for years. Of course, that's an official name from outside the English-speaking world.

I must admit, there's a contrived feeling to this story. The name is unofficial. Some of the stories mention that "South Lake Union" is an official name for neighborhoods that traditionally used other names--Cascade, etc.. One wonders if dubbing the light rail system the "S.L.U.T." is someone's revenge for that official designation.

Of course, it could be spontaneous. After all, what else might it have been called? S.L.U.S. isn't a word. (It's close to "slush," but no cigar.) "South Lake Union Railway?" Is S.L.U.R. much better?

Regardless, I'm enjoying the corny and predictable jokes about the S.L.U.T. getting around, about riding the S.L.U.T., about how the S.L.U.T. is easy to access. You get the idea. It's not many $51,000,000 transit projects that take on an air of being loose and lascivious.

Labels: , , ,

Wednesday, July 11, 2007

Hanging around with lanyards...

OK--question for all my readers: how do you define the word "lanyard?"

Somewhere, I'd heard that "lanyard" was a term for a badge that hangs from the neck. The "badge-holder"--as the convention organizers called it--seemed to fit my understanding of he term perfectly. The thing in question is a pouch, the front pocket designed with a window designed to display your name tag; the whole thing is worn dangling from your neck by a cord.

I noticed that no one else was using that term, and it made me wonder whether I might be misusing the term. Merriam-Webster's Online Dictionary--my usual online source for definitions--says that the term might apply to the cord holding the badge-holder, but not the whole badge-holder (cord included) itself. Another free online dictionary and Wikipedia both also back up this idea--though the former it was less certain that the term could be applied to the badge-holder's cord. (The definitions are consistent that it's a term for the cord suspending a knife or whistle.)

So, my questions for the Internet is simply these: Has anyone else used/heard he term "lanyard" (or "laniard," as it sometimes seems to be spelled) applied to a hanging badge/name tag? Also, is there a better term for such an object than "badge-holder?"

Labels:

Saturday, March 31, 2007

Konsumer protection at its dumbest

I had dinner at Koko's (a favorite local Japanese restaurant) tonight, and, as usual, ordered sushi. When I looked at the menu, my usual imitation crab was labeled "Krab stick." This struck me as very odd, since it was previously spelled correctly. Thinking they redid the menu and had a typo, I pointed it out to the waitress.

After my meal, she informed me that the restaurant indeed intended to spell it that way--it seems the state of Florida prohibits using the proper spelling of "crab" for imitation crab. Hence "krab."

Not wanting to dupe consumers is all well and good, but I think most people would not assume misspelling meant that the product was artificial or imitation on that basis alone. "Lether" wouldn't make me think "plastic," "golde" wouldn't make me think "less than 10K, if not zero gold," and "Teevo" wouldn't make me think "DVR but not TiVo." If I thought the crab stick were crab, "krab" wouldn't make me think otherwise.

Of course, "crab stick" is--at least at the restaurants I've been to--sushi code for the imitation crab, anyway. Changing "crab stick" to "krab stick" doesn't make that clear to someone who doesn't know what a "crab stick" is to begin with. And, in any case, the waitress didn't know why it was misspelled until she asked someone else--if the whole point was to call attention to the fact that it was imitation crab, the misspelling wouldn't have done the trick, since I only found out why it was "krab" when I had already eaten the sushi and was about to pay the check.

News flash to the state of Florida, department of health or whatever: insisting that imitation crab be called "krab" does not protect consumers--it needlessly makes innocent Japanese restauranteurs look illiterate. Don't state inspectors have better things to do than meddle with orthography?

Labels: , ,

Thursday, August 24, 2006

LANG - Looking at the planets again

The other day, I said I didn't have a problem with Ceres being reclassified as a planet. On further consideration, I'm not convinced this is a good idea. However, while not liking the first proposed definition for a planet, I'm not sure I like the IAU's latest proposal, either.

I tend to think that the term planet should be a definition that can be applied to an object that would apply irrespective of location. The more I think about it, the more I tend to think that even if a planet is ejected from a solar system or falls into orbit around a larger planet, it should still be considered a planet.

The core of the problem is that the term "planet" is a pre-scientific concept, and the original concept no longer can be considered valid in light of newer knowledge.

The word "planet" comes from a Greek word meaning "wandering star." Even though Copernicus himself used the term "wandering star" (for example, see the titles of Chapters 1 and 9 of Book VI of On the Revolutions of the Heavenly Spheres as translated by Charles Glenn Wallis), the concept of "wandering star" is now obsolete. The old concept arose because, except for the sun, moon, and comets (because of their tails), astronomic objects appear to be a point of light to the naked eye--so it's understandable why ancient people thought they were stars. The sun and moon were also classified as planets because of the way they moved through the sky. (Comets were not--until Edmond Halley's 1705 analysis, they were thought to be unpredictable--and because of eccentric orbits, many still are.)

"An object that is like Mercury, Venus, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, the sun, or the moon, but not like the Earth" would describe the ancient concept of a planet--but would be meaningless. We now know the sun is like the stars--or, using the ancient term, the "fixed stars"-- and different in appearance only due to our proximity to it. The similarity is that stars perform or performed (as in neutron stars) fusion. (For the moment, I'm ignoring brown dwarves.) Even before the underlying astrophysics were completely understood, differences could be seen. Planets in a telescope resolve to a disk, stars (except for the sun of course) to a point. Also, Galileo observed the phases of Venus--meaning Venus, and the other planets, reflected sunlight rather than shone with its own light. Stars, in contrast, do produce light.

The other shoe dropped when new objects were discovered--first Uranus in 1781, and then Ceres in 1801. Uranus clearly was a planet--though smaller in size, it was in many respects similar to Jupiter and Saturn. Ceres was a different story. Ceres was found after a search that was started when the newly-discovered Uranus conformed to a mathematical prediction that also suggested there should be a planet between Mars and Jupiter. (Many people dismiss that formula today--Neptune didn't fit the formula. Pluto would, but only if Neptune didn't exist.) However, Ceres was smaller than what the astronomers expected, so they kept looking. In the early 19th century, three other asteroids were discovered--and then nothing else for many years. As more asteroids were discovered in the asteroid belt, Ceres and the other three recently found "planets" there were reclassified as "asteroids"--though Uranus was not.

When Pluto was first discovered, it was described as being larger than the Earth. The article that cited that fact suggests it was mainly hype--though I'd wonder if expectation based on the location beyond the jovian planets and illusions created by the proximity of Charon and the large amount of ice on its surface might also have played into that claim. In any event, it isn't. However, though smaller than Mercury, it is larger than Ceres.

I tend to oppose Ceres being included in the list of planets because, while the ancient planets were all visible to the naked eye, Ceres--despite being within the orbit of Jupiter--is not. Visibility without magnification alone can't be the qualification since Neptune is much larger and more massive than any of the terrestrial planets, but is too distant to be seen unaided. Ceres generally can't be seen unaided, even though it's between two other objects (Mars and Jupiter) that can. (Visibility can also be subjective. Ceres, Vesta, and Uranus may be visible to the naked eye for a trained observer with sharp eyesight and optimal viewing conditions. In fact, they weren't documented before the invention of the telescope--which suggests naked-eye sightings would be very unusual.)

I don't like Pluto-Charon as a double planet--though I'd be happier with Charon as a planet if other major moons were also considered planets. Partly, it rubs me the wrong way because it makes Charon a planet, even though larger objects such as Earth's moon are not considered planets.

Also consider the case of a planet that only barely qualifies, and a smaller object that doesn't meet the normal minimal conditions for a planet, but is close enough in mass and distance to its planetary partner that the two orbit a common center of gravity above the surface of the planet. Would that be a double planet? If the first proposal of the IAU is adopted, but Quaoar is later determined to not be a planet, then Charon would be a planet solely by virtue of its location.

I don't like the idea of excluding Pluto and "Xena" solely because they're smaller than Mercury. (Sorry--I don't like unwieldy catalog numbers, either; I'd use it if I were looking for it with a telescope or writing a formal paper, but for writing in my blog, I'm using the nickname until it is formally named.) Consider this hypothetical object: Object X is both larger and heavier than Mercury, but similar composition to Pluto or Sedna and has a trans-Neptunian orbit. I know of no reason why such an object couldn't exist, or why it couldn't remain undiscovered. Sedna has an orbital period of more than 12,000 Earth years and an aphelion of nearly 93 billion miles/1000 AU. It's my understanding that an object large enough to be unquestionably a planet could easily escape detection at that distance, and who knows what's in the Kuiper Belts around other stars. A definition that somehow is designed to exclude Kuiper Belt objects would leave future astronomers stumbling over themselves to explain why Mercury is a planet, but Object X is not.

The second IAU proposal has a major problem in that it requires, "A planet [be] a celestial body that ... is by far the largest object in its local population...." Does that mean that if another star system has two objects just like Jupiter orbiting each other, then neither is a planet? If a rogue object of some sort passed through our solar system and knocked Venus into Earth's orbit at one of its LaGrange points, then both Venus and Earth lose their planetary status? The moon isn't a planet, but the object that hit the Earth to form the moon might have been, and the moon would be again if it escaped Earth's gravity? That doesn't seem like a good definition to me.

It's a nice idea to try to craft a definition independent of units of measurement, but many of the obvious criteria have problems. The existence of an atmosphere would likely include the smaller Pluto (which has a thin layer of nitrogen and methane, at least near its perihelion) but exclude the larger Mercury. Spherical shape doesn't work because different materials seem to be easier or harder to pull into such a shape--so again, you have the smaller Ceres in but the larger "Santa" out. Size relative to nearby objects doesn't work--though not contradicted yet, it's not possible this, too, could let in smaller objects only to exclude larger ones.

I tend to think the criteria should be simply "a planet is an object that is not a star but is above x kilograms in mass and/or y kilometers in diameter." Whether you use diameter, mass, or both and what x and y are will determine what is or isn't a planet.

You can also add to the definition the condition "and is not orbiting another planet." The more I think about it, the less I like that condition, since, in antiquity, the moon was considered a planet; based on that, I would tend to think larger moons should be included if they'd be planets in their own right were it not for their planetary orbit. Since I'm apparently in the minority in that view, I'd propose using the term "planetary moon" for a moon that would be a planet if it orbited independently, and leave well enough alone.

I also dislike the word "pluton" in this context. It has a definite and quite different meaning in geology and could create confusion for geologists who might study other planets. Wikipedia is already using the term "plutonian object." That strikes me as having a nice symmetry with the terms "terrestrial planets" and "jovian planets."

Were I writing the definition that had to exclude moons, I'd say, "a planet is any object that is not a star but is above 1022 kilograms in mass and is not orbiting another planet." That's a nice, round number. Under that definition, there would be 10 known planets--the four terrestrial planets: Mercury, Venus, Earth, and Mars; the four jovian planets: Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune; and two plutonian planets: Pluto, "Xena." There would also be 7 planetary moons--Earth's moon; Jupiter's Ganymede, Callisto, Io, and Europa; Saturn's Titan; and Neptune's Triton. To me, that is a reasonable definition. It includes the objects that have traditionally classified as planets--except for the relevant moons, the sun, and Ceres. (I think the moons should be included though most people don't, I agree with the consensus that the sun and Ceres they should be excluded.) As of now, there are no known objects near the cut-off line--though Pluto is not much above the line and some similar objects are below that number. (Pluto being near the cut-off is another reason why I like that definition--if there's debate about it, then that's probably about where the line should be.) It would also end future debate: find a new object, ask what it's mass is. Get an accurate answer, and you know if it's a planet or not.

It would be easy to craft a definition that would exclude Pluto and "Xena." "A planet is an object that is not a star but is above 2.0 * 1022 kilograms in mass and is not orbiting another planet." You have a nice round number and Pluto and "Xena" are out. Be very careful if you use that one, though: Triton is a plutonian planetary moon, and that strongly suggests that new discoveries may have the astronomers tripping over themselves with some future discovery of a large plutonian object. I wouldn't agree with the 2.0 * 1022 kilograms cut-off, in part because I think it's unwise to craft a definition that excludes Pluto but might include other plutonian planets. While I can easily live with some plutonian objects being planets while others are not, since asteroids such as Ceres are similar to terrestrial planets such as Mercury, I think that if you have some plutonian planets, then Pluto should be one of them.

I tend to be linguistically conservative--I like definitions that reflect both the etymology of the word and usage of the word--both current and traditional. For the word "planet," the etymology is largely useless--it relates to a geocentric cosmology that we now know to be erroneous. However, there are still useful traditions to fall back on. Pluto has been called a planet for 76 years--three generations is long enough to be a tradition, and is worth consideration. If Pluto is a planet, then the newly discovered "Xena" is a planet. I can live with that, also. I suppose I even like the notion--it's exciting to think that scientists are still discovering new planets in my lifetime.

The only mystery in my mind is the resistance to the idea of plutonian planets by some astronomers.

Labels:

Thursday, February 09, 2006

LANG - Anyone here speak Yiddish?

Does anyone reading this know the correct spelling for "fitschimmled?"

In my blog entry last night, I referred to a schedule possibly being "messed up." When I was writing that entry, I had originally planned on using what I thought was a synonym for that term--but one that I can't recall ever seen in writing, only hearing.

I tried Googling several spellings, tried looking it up on the Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary, and tried looking up an online Yiddish dictionary. (And then another. And another after that.) A nice trip down a linguistic memory lane from living near New York, and hearing all the good Yiddishisms that find their way into your lexicon if you live in that part of the country, but other than that, nada. Zilch.

I decided to ask my dad at lunch today about the word--he thought it might be two words, and that the second word might be "related to 'shlemiel.'" Worth a shot. Back to the Yiddish dictionaries and Google. Maybe "fitschimmled" might be "feh shlemiel," which, as far as I can determine, would mean "disgusting idiot." However, I can't find any evidence that "feh shlemiel" is used as a phrase in typical use--or that it's gramatticaly correct Yiddish. Nor can I find any evidence for its use as a verb in English. I'm also convinced the word I'd heard in the past had a "t" sound in it. So I don't think I've found what I was looking for.

Oy Gevalt--it's enough to make one meshugina.


Labels:

Tuesday, February 15, 2000

Rating the ratings

The MPAA rating system
Overall Rating: ****


Everyone knows what "R-rated" and "G-rated" mean. That's why the rating system devised by the Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA) works.

In the 1920s, there was great concern that movies were getting too violent and too racy. In response, seven major studios formed the MPAA, and agreed on the Hays Production Code. The Hays Code was a strict set of rules restricting what could and couldn't be shown in movies. The MPAA would approve or disapprove any movie submitted, and the studios agreed not to release movies that violated the code. By the mid-1960s, however, directors with the major Hollywood studios were starting to gripe that they were being unfairly constrained. In 1966, MGM's director Michelangelo Antonioni made "Blow-Up." Because "Blow-Up" had full frontal nudity, it was denied certification by the MPAA--but MGM released it anyway. To prevent future crises, the MPAA devised four ratings, roughly modeled on a system previously developed by the Catholic Church. Anyone submitting a movie to the MPAA for a rating would be given one of four ratings--G, M, R, or X (all movies not MPAA rated would be considered X-rated; the other three ratings were trademarked to prevent misapplication).

Since implemented in the 1960s, the rating system has gone through some minor changes. M became PG; X became NC-17. An additional rating, PG-13, was added. The MPAA now makes public the reason(s) why a movie got a PG or stronger rating. The basic system still stands, however, and does what it was designed to: allows directors and producers a free hand regarding content, but also provides parents and theaters some guide to adult content.

There are still films not primarily intended for children that are made without the R-rated content; for instance, "The Boy Who Could Fly," "October Sky," and "Life is Beautiful" have content that is probably muted enough for the whole family (and probably would be approved under the old Hays Code with little or no modification). Even so, I don't think anyone would question that many films have gratuitous sex and violence. Have movies gone too far? Films filled with sex, violence, and gore are often hugely profitable. A large portion of the public actively wants the strong content, or at least doesn't object to it enough to stop going to movies with graphic elements.

As long as there's a demand for movies with salacious content, there will be a supply. The existence of modern technology makes it impossible to return to a Hays-Code-like system. Consider "The Blair Witch Project." One of last summer's big hits at the box office, it was made by a group of film students for $40,000. Consider, also, the pornographic movie industry. There is a demand for movies with stronger sexual content than mainstream producers will tolerate (indeed, this may still be on an MPAA disapproved list--I've read conflicting sources on this point). That doesn't prevent the existence of a supply--countless obscure companies produce hundreds if not thousands of titles each year--almost always releasing them directly on video or the Internet. If the big, American entertainment companies eschewed R-rated content, maverick smaller companies and foreign producers would quickly fill the void. And what would happen to the movies already out there?

Nor would it be desirable to return to a strict "approve or disapprove" system. Sex and violence have been a part of both popular and high culture at least since the days of Homer. Granted some movies demean themselves with pointless on-screen sex and violence, but that's not always the case. The problem with the Hays Code becomes immediately apparent when you try to picture "A Clockwork Orange," "Blazing Saddles," and "Breaking the Waves"--or, to cite three examples from last year alone, "Fight Club," "South Park," and "Eyes Wide Shut"--toned down enough to earn a PG rating (essentially, the limit of the Hays Code). Graphic content can be used to make a point, or it can be just vulgar entertainment; in both cases, sometimes it works, and sometimes it doesn't--whether or not it works, however, is an artistic concern. It's there, and some people want it but other people might object to it; that's why the rating system is desirable.

Is the current rating system perfect? Of course not. A movie's rating is decided by a board of about a dozen people who evaluate the film as a whole based on fixed guidelines. Some of the MPAA's guidelines are downright crazy. For instance, a movie can show a murder on screen, and still get a PG rating, but simply showing a marijuana cigarette requires a PG-13 rating. Sometimes the board misses. Looking back at my reviews, of 71 MPAA-rated movies I've reviewed, only 13 were misrated in my opinion. Of those, I thought nine were too harshly rated, and four were too leniently rated. Three of those four, "Fight Club," "The General's Daughter," "South Park" would have received an NC-17 from me--a financial kiss of death. That brings me to another problem; since NC-17-rated films often fair poorly at the box office compared to R-rated films, there is often a conflict between the studios, who are willing to recut and reedit their films for an R rating, and directors who are concerned about artistic integrity. For example, "Eyes Wide Shut" featured several digitally added people and plants, blocking more explicit shots, to allow the movie to be rated R--with the result that Kubrick purists were howling about the tampering with his final film. (I'd like to have seen the film as Kubrick intended--but I have no basis to judge how badly the film was "damaged" since I haven't seen the unedited version.) Splitting R into two ratings, one picking up some of the borderline NC-17 films, might solve the problem. Perhaps a better solution was proposed by Jack Valenti, the president of the MPAA, when the rating system was created. According to his article on the MPAA website, he opposed the X rating, believing, as I do, that parents should be allowed to take their children to any film they feel to be suitable. The MPAA included the adults only rating because an association of theater owners was worried about legal liability.

I used to think it would be a good idea to have separate ratings for violence, sex, drug use, language, and thematic content; in short, I used to wish that the MPAA ratings would be replaced by something more like today's TV rating system--however, of the various rating systems devised by the music, television, movie, and video-game industries, the television ratings are easily the most arcane. Since the MPAA makes the reason for any PG or stricter rating available on their website, they don't need to create a code that the NSA couldn't decipher--parents who want to know why a movie is rated R can look up the reasons, or, they accept the R rating without investigation.

The MPAA system is also far preferable to no rating system. Movie promotions are too often vague, inept, or outright misleading to rely on them as a guide to whether a film is family-oriented. (If you don't think ads can be misleading, consider that, based on the previews, I had no interest in "The Sixth Sense," but actively wanted to see "Supernova;" the former is easily among the best films of last year, while the latter is this year's big turkey so far.)

It would be easy to say that in an ideal world, parents would screen every film their children see; but then again, would such a screening even be necessary in an ideal world? In any event, we don't live in an ideal world. I have always made it a point to evaluate movies for violence, sex, drug content, strong language, and strong thematic content in my reviews; some of my readers have misconstrued my comments about the presence of such content for being a complaint about that content--they're not always (though I will criticize about what I perceive as gratuitous). Beyond my service, there are other services whose sole focus is providing this type of information. Neither my service nor the other services, however, are universal. The MPAA's rating system is; movie theaters always display a film's rating with the title on their marquee or sign, on the posters, and/or at the box office. All movie ads and previews, unless far in advance of a film's release, also show the film's rating.

The MPAA rating system isn't perfect, but as long as movies show material that some parents regard as unsuitable for their children, the rating system is an excellent means to acknowledge these parents' concerns and while preserving artistic freedom.


For more information about the history of the MPAA rating system, visit the MPAA's website:
http://www.mpaa.org
Jack Valenti's article on the rating system can be found at:
http://www.mpaa.org/movieratings/about/index.htm [This link is not working as of August 2009.]


Original URL: http://www.geocities.com/Hollywood/Mansion/7045/_MPAA.htm
Added to blog site: 8/5/09

Labels: , ,